Justice Brett Kavanaugh wants you to believe that letting a local government sue an oil company for lying about climate change will somehow dismantle the American economy.
During the Supreme Court's October 5, 2026 oral arguments in Suncor Energy (U.S.A.) Inc. v. County Commissioners of Boulder County, Kavanaugh laid out a dramatic warning. He suggested that allowing Colorado municipalities to bring state-law claims against fossil fuel producers could "bankrupt" the industry. He asked how a tort lawsuit differs from a state legislature passing a law to cap emissions across all 50 states, arguing that "anyone is a potential defendant for a suit like this". For a different look, see: this related article.
It sounds alarming on the surface. It is also completely upside down.
Kavanaugh is flipping basic legal principles on their head to shield ExxonMobil and Suncor Energy from ever facing a jury. By conflating financial accountability for consumer deception with federal emissions regulation, his reasoning ignores decades of established precedent, misreads the exact cases he cites, and treats corporate survival as a valid reason to throw out a lawsuit before evidence is even heard. Similar coverage on this matter has been shared by Al Jazeera.
What the Boulder Climate Lawsuit Actually Claims
To see why Kavanaugh's argument fails, you first have to look at what Boulder County and the City of Boulder are actually suing over.
When Boulder filed its lawsuit back in 2018, the community was already dealing with the real-world fallout of extreme weather—devastating wildfires, severe floods, and rising infrastructure costs. Local officials didn't ask a Colorado judge to shut down oil refineries in Texas or set national carbon caps. They sued Suncor and ExxonMobil under traditional Colorado tort and consumer protection laws, alleging that the companies knowingly misled the public for decades about the dangers of burning fossil fuels while continuing to market and sell those products in Colorado.
There is a massive legal difference between regulating smokestacks and punishing fraud.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor cut straight to that distinction during the October 2026 hearing. She pointed out that the Clean Air Act governs air pollution, not corporate marketing campaigns. "The Clean Air Act does not regulate marketing or advertising of fuel," Sotomayor noted, questioning how holding a company liable for false advertising interferes with federal environmental rules.
Even Chief Justice John Roberts acknowledged that state courts routinely hear tort claims involving conduct that spans multiple states. When a product sold locally causes local damage, people get to sue in their home state. That is tort law 101.
The Four Precedents Kavanaugh Misread
Kavanaugh's core legal pitch during oral arguments was that the Supreme Court doesn't need to "reinvent the wheel". He claimed a quartet of older Supreme Court cases already proves that interstate pollution disputes belong exclusively under federal law unless Congress explicitly preserves state lawsuits.
Those four cases are Illinois v. City of Milwaukee (1972), Milwaukee v. Illinois (1981), International Paper Co. v. Ouellette (1987), and American Electric Power Co. v. Connecticut (2011).
When Suncor's lawyer confirmed that Boulder was suing under Colorado law—the law of the state suffering the injury—Kavanaugh immediately declared, "Okay. That resolves this case".
Except it doesn't. Legal scholars have pointed out that Kavanaugh's reading turns those precedents inside out.
Why Those Cases Don't Shield Big Oil
- Federal common law isn't the same as state statutory or tort law. In Milwaukee I and Milwaukee II, the Court dealt with federal common law nuisance claims over raw sewage dumped into Lake Michigan, eventually ruling that the Clean Water Act displaced those specific federal judge-made claims. Displacement of federal common law does not automatically wipe out state-law remedies.
- State deception claims weren't on the table in AEP. In American Electric Power v. Connecticut, states sued major power utilities directly to force caps on their carbon dioxide emissions under federal common law. Boulder isn't asking a court to set emissions limits for power plants. It is seeking damages for local adaptation costs driven by corporate misrepresentation.
- Congress never silently erased state fraud laws. Under standard preemption doctrine, federal statutes only override traditional state police powers—like protecting consumers from deceptive business practices—when Congress makes that intent unmistakably clear. Kavanaugh flips that presumption backward, insisting state law is dead unless Congress specifically wrote a permission slip into the Clean Air Act.
Justice Elena Kagan exposed the weakness of the oil companies' constitutional fallback theory during the argument. When industry lawyers argued that the basic structure of the Constitution implicitly bars states from hearing climate suits, Kagan fired back: "Where's the text for that? Where's the support for that? Where's the precedent for that? Where's the anything for that?" Even Justice Amy Coney Barrett called the companies' constitutional preemption argument "a little slippery".
Tort Damages Are Not State Legislation
One of Kavanaugh's favorite talking points from the bench was equating a jury verdict with a state statute. "So why is the state tort suit different than the state law?" he asked Boulder's attorney. "I'm just not understanding that".
Honest answer? Because a law commands behavior, while a damages award prices harm.
If Colorado passed a statute making it illegal to refine oil in Texas or ordering ExxonMobil to cut global output by 30 percent, that would be direct extraterritorial regulation. Courts strike down laws like that all the time.
A tort verdict does nothing of the sort. If a Colorado jury finds that Suncor and ExxonMobil deceived consumers and awards Boulder money to pay for wildfire mitigation and flood walls, the companies remain completely free to produce, refine, and sell oil however they choose. They simply have to pay for the damage caused by their conduct—just like any other business.
The Supreme Court settled this exact distinction more than forty years ago in Silkwood v. Kerr-McGee Corp. (1984). In Silkwood, the Court ruled that a state jury could award punitive damages against a nuclear facility operator even though the federal government holds exclusive regulatory authority over nuclear safety. The justices explicitly recognized that while damages might indirectly influence corporate behavior, paying compensation for injuries is fundamentally different from direct government regulation.
Kavanaugh's refusal to see the difference between a regulatory mandate and a compensatory damages check erases decades of American tort jurisprudence.
The Bankruptcy Myth and the Tobacco Playbook
Perhaps the most revealing moment of the October 2026 argument was Kavanaugh's worry that lawsuits like Boulder's could "bankrupt" fossil fuel companies.
Think about what that implies. Courts exist to determine whether a defendant broke the law and caused measurable harm—not to act as financial bodyguards for multi-billion-dollar corporations. Whether a defendant can easily afford a judgment has never been the legal test for whether a plaintiff gets a trial.
Justice Kagan dismantled both the legal novelty and the doomsday framing by pointing directly to history. She described Boulder's case as "Chapter 3" in a familiar legal trilogy—following the 1990s lawsuits against Big Tobacco and the more recent litigation against pharmaceutical companies over the opioid crisis.
"This is the same kind of lawsuit against the same kind of actors for the same kind of harm," Kagan said from the bench. "And I guess I'm not understanding how this one would be preempted and the other is not?"
Look at how Chapters 1 and 2 actually played out:
- Big Tobacco didn't vanish. When states sued cigarette makers for hiding the addictive and lethal nature of nicotine, industry lawyers predicted total economic collapse. Cigarette companies still sell products today, though they were forced to stop lying to the public and pay billions to offset state healthcare costs.
- Pharma survived accountability. Opioid manufacturers and distributors paid massive settlements for deceptive marketing practices that fueled a public health crisis, yet legitimate pain medications remain on pharmacy shelves across the country.
- Juries separate valid claims from frivolous ones. Kavanaugh warned that letting Boulder proceed means "any manufacturer, any business" could be sued. In reality, plaintiffs still have to clear massive evidentiary hurdles—proving specific deceptive conduct, causation, and quantifiable local damages before a single dollar changes hands.
Right now, Boulder hasn't won a dime. The Colorado Supreme Court simply ruled in 2025 that the lawsuit wasn't preempted by federal law and could move forward to discovery and trial. ExxonMobil and Suncor are asking the U.S. Supreme Court to slam the courthouse doors shut before Boulder can even present its internal industry documents to a jury.
Why the Timing of This Appeal Raises Red Flags
There is another layer to this case that makes Kavanaugh's eagerness to toss the suit even harder to justify—jurisdiction.
Normally, the U.S. Supreme Court only reviews final judgments after a state court system has finished handling a case. Here, the Colorado courts haven't held a trial, haven't issued a final judgment, and haven't even ruled on several of the oil companies' remaining defenses.
When the justices agreed to hear the appeal, they actually added a threshold question of their own asking whether they even have legal authority to decide the case at this preliminary stage. During oral arguments, justices across the ideological spectrum—including Clarence Thomas, Sonia Sotomayor, and Ketanji Brown Jackson—questioned why the high court was stepping in piecemeal before Colorado courts finished their work.
"We're really early in this case," Justice Jackson observed. "Why shouldn't we wait and hear all of these claims once the state courts are done with their federal considerations?"
With Justice Samuel Alito recused from the case, only eight justices are participating. That means if the Court splits 4–4—or if pivotal conservative votes like Justices Neil Gorsuch and Amy Coney Barrett conclude that the appeal is premature or that state deception claims survive—the Colorado Supreme Court's decision stands and Boulder finally gets its trial.
How to Track the Case and Hold Corporate Accountability Front and Center
The Supreme Court's ruling in Suncor Energy v. Boulder County, expected by summer 2027, will determine the fate of dozens of similar climate accountability lawsuits filed by cities, counties, and states nationwide. You don't have to sit on the sidelines waiting for the opinion to drop.
- Read the primary source documents. Pull up the official October 5, 2026 oral argument transcript on the Supreme Court's website or review the Colorado Supreme Court's underlying ruling to compare what the justices actually asked against fossil-fuel industry talking points.
- Check whether your municipality or state has an active climate deception case. States from California and Massachusetts to Minnesota, alongside dozens of local governments, have filed consumer fraud and public nuisance suits seeking infrastructure reimbursement rather than taxpayer-funded bailouts.
- Push local officials to separate infrastructure costs from general tax hikes. When extreme weather damages roads, water systems, or power grids, demand transparency from city councils and county commissioners on how much those repairs cost taxpayers—and whether your jurisdiction is pursuing recovery from companies that profited while hiding the risks.
For more on how this unfolded in the courtroom, watch Brett Kavanaugh Presses Lawyer On Court Climate Precedents, which captures the exact exchange where Kavanaugh pressed counsel on federal versus state pollution boundaries during the October 5 oral arguments.